Andrew and Cheyenne's story began in January 2016, at a house party hosted by Jessica (bridesmaid). Mike (Andrew's brother/groomsmen) worked with Cheyenne and Jessica at Red Robin. Mike brought Andrew and two friends, Vanderver and Michael (both groomsmen) to the party where Andrew and Cheyenne met for the first time. They instantly had a connection with being too competitive during a beer pong game, and ended up exchanging numbers the next day. Andrew and Cheyenne went out on a couple dates the next few weeks, but things eventually fizzled out. Fast forward to July of 2017, where Andrew and Cheyenne happened to be staying at the same campsite at Night in the Country. From there, the sparks rekindled, and the two have been together ever since.