Katie and Tucker both grew up in Alexandria and can remember each other from church and acolyting but didn't know each other well. After a reintroduction by Tucker's mom, Laura, (it was not a setup) they realized that they both lived 7 blocks away from each other on the Upper East Side. Planning to get drinks so it wouldn't be awkward on their carpool ride to Martha's Vineyard, they met for drinks at the Supply House and haven't spent a day apart (other than work travel) since. They quickly realized that this was something real, decided to go full hog and haven't looked back.