After two and a half years of online dating, on September 28, 2019, Shayne traveled halfway across the country to New York to meet Sarah for the first time. Sarah picked Shayne up at LaGuardia Airport on a sunny, warm afternoon, and they had instant chemistry! Their first meal together was at Boston Market in Garden City. Shayne planned a romantic first date for Sarah — a horse-drawn carriage ride through Central Park. He even surprised her with a dozen red roses! From being dazzled by the bright lights of Times Square, to marveling at pygmy spears in the Museum of Natural History, to playing mini-golf together, Sarah and Shayne had a magical time on their first trip. They look back fondly on this day. Six years later, they'll be tying the knot on a day that already holds so much meaning for them.