Kyle is known for his obsession with pickles, so it didn't phase Shay that he wanted to make a day trip to a specialty pickle shop, Freakin' Pickles, located 2 hours north of Detroit and explore the surrounding area. They decided to check out a local State Park. Shay knew something was up, the minute they entered the park, as Kyle got really quiet (which never happens), and started sprinting on their walk. Kyle knows Shay's love for lighthouses so it was the perfect spot to pop the question! He might have given it away at the State Park, but Kyle pulled off the best surprise by having some of their closet friends and family members waiting at their home (and virtually!) when they got back from their day trip. It was the perfect lakeside proposal and intimate celebration.