After a super like on tinder, coupled with Shafer's "great" flirting skills, Claire wasn't even sure if it was a date. After chatting for over a month, Claire finally accepted Shafer's request to go out, the third time was the charm. Claire's biggest concern when Shafer suggested they go to the dog park, is that Guinness would eat Bongo before they even arrived. Turns out Bongo and Guinness were destined to be brothers. Claire knew Shafer was a good one because Guinness gave his seal of approval. After a few more dates, Shafer started saving for an engagement ring and the rest is history.