Sarah laughed at Elliot's jokes at an improv show where he was an audience member. Elliot met Sarah at her Prom, and continues to tell jokes. A few weeks go by, and their mutual friend or matchmaker, Lorin, sets them up on their first date. Elliot asked Sarah " to go out?" and Sarah says "No." That was the start to a wonderful joke that they still talk about to this day. Sarah changed her answer, and they dated for 9 years before Elliot popped the question. They have been separated by long distances, lost people they loved, got into their first car accidents within days of each other, graduated college, moved to NYC, had horrible jobs, traveled to England and found their love overcame it all.
At sunset on the James.