Long before Sal and Sam began dating, Sal would jokingly ask Sam to "hold something" for him while holding his hand towards hers. When she would go to grab it, he would take her hand in his. This joke quickly became a sweet moment shared often between the two. Flash forward six years, to when the two were sitting on the couch in their apartment listening to their favorite band, the Foo Fighters. Sal put on their favorite song, Everlong, and once again asked Sam to "hold something" for him. This time, when Sam went to hold his hand, she gasped as she felt a ring drop into hers. Sal got down on one knee and asked her to marry him. She said yes and the two immediately went to share the moment with their families.