Sam and Kayleigh first crossed paths in high school, but their lives never quite converged. Fast forward to 2020, and the pandemic brought both of them back to their hometown. In the midst of uncertain times in early 2021, fate intervened, and they reconnected. While unable to go on many traditional dates, they got to know each other quickly over a deck of TableTopics, a conversation starter game that became the foundation for their connection. The more they talked, the more they discovered shared interests, complimentary viewpoints, and life goals. Before long, they decided to take the plunge and move in together in New Jersey. Along the way, they welcomed two loving rescue pups, Honey and Chex, who quickly became an integral part of their family. Sam and Kayleigh's love story look a magical turn during a family trip to St. John. After a storm passed, Sam proposed on a nearly empty Cinnamon Bay beach during sunset. This special place will always hold a cherished memory, and they hope to return during their honeymoon. Their journey from high school acquaintances to life partners is a testament to the unexpected and beautiful turns that life can take.