Hotel
This was the best balance of price, convenience, and positive reviews that we could find. The hotel is a quick 10-minute car ride from the wedding venue and is very close to the subway into Manhattan (approx. 10 minutes to the Lower East Side). While the hotel is not in an especially beautiful area of Brooklyn (elevated train tracks, can be loud and dirty), it is close to some solid hipster-y bars and restaurants (Ornithology Jazz Club, Wonderville, Santa Panza). Mention the Johnson-Olson Wedding if calling to make reservation or book with the provided link.
Hotel
This is the more luxurious option. It's located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, which is a great neighborhood very close to where the happy couple lives. It's a nice, modern hotel that is walkable to anything you could want (shopping, bars, restaurants, rehearsal dinner) and is directly above a subway entrance. 5 minute train into Manhattan, 10 minute car to the wedding venue. Mention the Johnson-Olson Wedding if calling to make reservation or book with the provided link.