The couple was set with the task of removing a Christmas wreath from the banister of the veterinary hospital they worked at together. Sabrina valiantly insisted on climbing up the ladder to prove how tough she was to her coworker and Brandon settled for watching her climb up. Unfortunately, Brandon was distracted and the ladder collapsed, dropping his future fiance 8 feet to the ground. Sabrina "fell for" Brandon right then and there!

Brandon planned a surprise get-away weekend at Seneca Lake, NY for Sabrina's birthday. They wined and dined on the finest grapes the Finger Lakes could offer. Little did she know, Brandon had a second surprise waiting for her. While hiking down the Lover's Lane trail at the Watkins Glen State Park, the duo came across a lookout point to take in the views of the gorge. Sabrina began talking about the couple's future together, unknowingly taking the thunder away from Brandon's big speech. Brandon walked over to Sabrina, got down on one knee and asked her to marry him! She said "YES" through her tears of joy!