Travel Note
For the sake of ease, we have chosen accommodation options on Shelter Island. We will be offering shuttle service to and from these accommodations throughout the weekend, so do not stress about needing a car! Should you wish to stay in Greenport, Sag Harbor, or anywhere else on the North and South Forks, please keep in mind that a car will be a necessity. North Ferry service runs until 1 AM and the South Ferry until 2 AM, but some of the activities we have scheduled may run later than these times...plan accordingly!
Travel Note
The only way to reach Shelter Island is by ferry. Two ferries run to the island: the NORTH FERRY from GREENPORT via the North Fork of Long Island and the SOUTH FERRY from NORTH HAVEN, SAG HARBOR via the South Fork/Hamptons. Please note that both ferries are CASH ONLY. NORTH FERRY: 5:00am- 1:00am (departs from Greenport every 5-10 minutes). $2 walk on, $12 in a car (with up to 3 passengers, each additional passenger is $2 more). SOUTH FERRY: 5:40am- 1:45 am (departs from North Haven every 10-15 minutes). $2 walk on, $15 in a car.
Train
The Jitney is, in our opinion, the best way to get out to the island. Buses depart from various locations in the city and Brooklyn hourly. Select the North Fork line with your destination as Greenport. The bus drops you off right by the entrance to the North Ferry.
Train
The LIRR runs from Penn Station to Greenport several times a day, and drops you off at the entrance to the North Ferry.
Hotel
We have reserved all 20 rooms at the Sunset Beach Hotel so that guests may dance with us til dawn! Please contact Ruby if you would like to book one of these rooms.
Hotel
This boutique hotel has several gorgeous suites that would suit large families well. Please book online through their website!
Hotel
A landmark hotel right in the center of town with a lovely restaurant attached. Online booking available now!
House Or Rental
The Candlelite Inn is a 181 year old Victorian, situated on one and a half acres in the center of Shelter Island. Recently redecorated, The Candlelite Inn has 5 guest rooms with private baths, central air conditioning, television in the common living room and offers a continental breakfast. This B&B is a more reasonably priced option on the island! Call for availability.
House Or Rental
A waterfront house just steps away from Shell Beach (one of Ruby and Gabriel's favorites)!
House Or Rental
This rental comes with kayaks, bikes, and a cute loft bedroom.
House Or Rental
Honor the bride's love of boats with a unique opportunity to stay on one! This beauty sleeps four and can be anchored at Sunset Beach!!