In April 2023, Andrew decided to plan a big, romantic dinner while the two were vacationing in Guatemala to pop the question. The moment was set while they made their pit stop in Antigua. But unfortunately, his plans were foiled because both of them ended up catching a nasty cold. Andrew had to think of a new plan and fast since he brought the ring all the way from the U.S. He waited until the two felt better while at their last destination in Moterrico. On one of their final days in Guatemala, he took Sara for a walk on the beach and got down on one knee and proposed. Sara of course said yes.