From the beginning, Casey told Wyatt that she had a few wishes if he ever decided to propose. First, was she wanted her hair and nails done. Second, was that she wanted pictures of the moment to cherish forever. Every year Casey and Wyatt have photos for Christmas Cards, and this year had been no different. Leading up to the day, Casey would make jokes about how at their Christmas card photo session all her “criteria” would have been met. Wyatt would always reply with “That’s too obvious. I will do it when you least expect it”. On October 24th, 2020, the two woke up and got ready for photos for later that evening. Upon arrival at Stokoe Farms in Scottsville NY it seemed to be like any other photo session. Shortly after they arrived, they walked into the corn maze to get some photos. As they round a corner, they see a table surrounded by pumpkins, with a vase full of roses and champagne with two glasses on the table. Casey, remembering what Wyatt said about it being too obvious for him to propose that day, said “We need to get out of here. Someone is getting engaged.” and kept walking. Wyatt flabbergasted, exclaimed, “Yeah, it’s yours.” Casey turned around bawling to see Wyatt had dropped to one knee and he then asked her to spend the rest of their lives together. Casey, of course, said “YES!”