On August 1, 2025, Natalie and Ben were headed to dinner with Natalie's friends and family. It just so happened that the parents were "running late" and they had to kill some time before getting dinner. Kailie, Natalie's best friend (who was in on the surprise), suggested they go up to Lookout Mountain to one of Natalie's favorite spots, Sunset Rock. Hesitant because she wore heels (and NOT her hiking boots), Natalie agreed to hike down. When they got there, the couples took turns taking pictures behind the beautiful scenery. When it was time for Ben and Natalie's photo, Ben got down on one knee and proposed. And of course, she said yes!