When moving into Manhattan, Jill searched on Craigslist to find roommates to move in with. Who would have ever expected what that would lead to... upon moving in, Jill and PJ were roommates along with another friend. it didn't take long for the relationship to blossom. Six years later, they officially got married in town court, but didn't consider it to be a true wedding without exchanging vows surrounded by immediate family. On April 23, 2021 in Montauk, NY, they tied the knot on their original wedding date prior to the postponement. Finally, they will have another ceremony and reception with all friends and family on April 29, 2022, in South Salem, NY. Third time is a charm! #CraigslistToCaretsky #ThreesAcharm