No surprise here, Jessy and Sara met on a dating app. (Hinge, if you're curious.) They talked about John Carpenter's Halloween and true crime documentaries until finally, Sara asked, "Do you want to do this or what?"

You might think you're on the wrong wedding website, but Jessy and her friends are the few people who know Sara as "Sam."

Jessy threatened that she would say "no" if there was a big fuss, so Sara proposed with flowers and a card in their kitchen. Jessy's exact response was, "Are you serious? Are YOU serious?"