Justin and Peyton's love story started with a pair of right swipes... except Justin forgot to message Peyton back for three weeks. To make a long story short, a first date in October 2024 involving burgers and a set-off smoke alarm made the $20 Justin spent on the premium subscription for a second chance all worth it. He did, in fact, tell Peyton it was only $5. Pretty soon, Justin became the most frequent driver of NC-903, the main stretch of highway between Williamston and Greenville. By November 03, 2024, Justin had met the parents and by November 28, 2024, Peyton and Justin were spending holidays together. The next year together involved a lot of changes. Justin and Peyton tried to get Athena and Yam, their pets, to be friends after moving. Peyton joked on a couple occasions that she'd be fine if Justin asked her to marry him in her pajamas. Justin came clean that it was not only $5 to restore the match. Justin started hatching a proposal idea he thought Peyton would love. On November 21, 2025, the day the ring was in his hands, all those plans went out the window and he proposed that night at their home. She said yes (in her pajamas).