Peter and Maggie met on Hinge, a dating app, where Peter commented on Maggie's prompt regarding her love for Skyline. This seemingly mutual enthusiasm for Cincinnati's favorite chili led Maggie to agree to a date. Turns out - his response was a total lie. Peter had never had Skyline in his life. Their first date at Clark Street Ale House was a success. 5 years later, they live together in Lakeview, a Chicago neighborhood. They are thankful they disobeyed their mothers and did in fact meet a stranger from the internet. Peter has since tried Skyline, and "doesn't understand why someone would eat this sober." Maggie loves him anyway.