When Pawel decided to get drinks with his best man Justin on a random Thursday night, little did he know that they would be walking into Caitlin’s first shift at Jackalope and that he would start paying for this wedding that night. Over the next several months, Pawel would come by to flirt and chat with his favorite bartender in town, always dragging his friends there with the promise of buying a few rounds. After a few months of playing hard to get, Caitlin finally decided it was okay to date a customer…

The two were engaged during a private picnic at the Chandon Winery.