Natalie always saw Eric on campus (I mean, he's pretty hard to miss) and ramming into people on the rugby field. She developed a crush on him, but always felt he was out of her league. Eric always saw Natalie at Greek life functions, and found her intense loves for cats and iced coffee totally quirky and charming. He developed a crush on her, but always felt she was out of his league. Somewhere along the way, the stud and the hipster fell in love.

Contrary to Natalie's first impression of Eric, she soon learned that he had absolutely no game. So it's no wonder his proposal took place at 11:30pm on a Monday between watching The Bachelorette and Ocean's 12. The ring box was under the bed and when he popped up with it, he gave some super romantic speech that Natalie completely ignored (assuming it was a joke). Once she realized it was real, the tears started flowing and she asked him to repeat the speech. He teared up too, and said he just blacked out and couldn't remember a word. She said yes anyways.