On a cold winter night, after having a broken stove for a whole month, Paige hurried home from work as her landlord hired someone to fix it. Her landlord had a preferred plumber, little did she know, this would change Paige's life. Moments after she got home there was a knock on the door, when she opened it, there stood Allen, as she looked at him, she was instantly attracted. They were both taken back with each other, as their encounter was not what either one of them were expecting, in fact while standing in the kitchen, Allen actually asked Paige "where is the stove." Paige left Allen to do his work, and went upstairs to message her landlord Jesse, saying "You did not tell me the plumber was going to be HOT". Allen then yelled up the stairs, "are you still here", Paige awkwardly responded "No...", he replied "okay.... well I need to go and get a part for the stove, I'll be right back". Paige then came down stairs, and apologized for her response, as she claimed to be "distracted". While Allen was out getting the part, Paige proceeded to put some make-up on, post some hilarious things about their encounter on Twitter, all while panicking because Jesse told her he was going to tell Allen what she had said. She did not want it to be more awkward when he came back than it already was. When Allen returned he told her he was not able to get the part, he gave her his card and said that he would have to come back and to call him if she needed anything.... and the rest is history!

During a Santa party hosted by Paige at her mom and Mikes house, Allen had prepared to pop the question. As Mike and Linda were getting into their Mr & Mrs Claus costumes, Allen went up stairs and let them know he was putting the ring into a stocking. Paige sat Kaleb down onto Santa’s knee and as they were about to take the picture Dave, Allen's step dad, told Paige to kneel down (not knowing what was going to happen.) Allen then said I'll kneel down too. He then asked “what do you want for Christmas Paige?,” Paige was not fully paying attention, and jokingly she replied "Kaleb's two front teeth" and Allen then pulled the ring box out of the stocking, said “all I want for Christmas is you" opened the box, and said "will you marry me” and amongst the tears of excitement she said “are you serious?, yes baby of course I will”