We met on OkCupid, right when Judy was about to throw her phone into the ocean and swear off online dating forever. Enter Jordan, sliding into her DMs like a digital knight in shining armor. His opening line? Asking about her favorite musical. Judy instantly knew this guy was different—because, let’s be real, most messages were barely coherent, and here’s someone talking theater. A whole week of nonstop texting about everything under the sun followed before we even met IRL. Our first date was on May 17, 2018. In classic Jordan fashion, he kept it classy—Starbucks and a movie. (What? Don’t judge; coffee and superheroes are a winning combo.) Jordan made the epic journey from Co-Op City to the Upper East Side to meet Judy, and we watched the first Infinity Wars movie together. But the real magic happened afterward: we ended up talking the night away at Judy’s apartment. Jordan was clearly smitten because he ate the burnt quesadilla Judy forgot in the oven, too distracted by their deep and meaningful convo to notice she was completely sabotaging dinner. The rest is history.