Kelly and Nick flew to Hawaii in October of 2020 the day Hawaii opened again to mainland travel. Nick made a reservation at the CanoeHouse at Mauna Lani Bay Hotel. The couple arrived early and walked the beach prior to sitting down for dinner. They sat on a log and watched the sunset over the water. As they stood up to head to dinner, Nick got down on one knee and asked Kelly to be his forever. The photo below is where the proposal took place.