NIck and Caitlin grew up in the same circles of friends. They went on several missions trips together and were both at many social events. It was not until shortly after Caitlin's 16th birthday party that they both started noticing each other with new eyes. They started dating six months after that, and #therestisreisenauer.

Caitlin had been begging Nick to take her to the Aspen trees in Flagstaff. Nick thought this was the perfect opportunity to surprise her with the proposal of a lifetime. Nick and Caitlin were set to meet some friends to go on this beautiful hike. Unbenounced to Caitlin, Nick had planned for those friends to cancel right before they got to the hike. When, they arrived at the hike, Caitlin started noticing how jittery Nick was. Nick was nervous but excited. They hiked about 30 minutes up the mountain and stopped at a beautiful inlet off the trail. Nick asked Caitlin if she wanted a piece of gum but instead pulled out a ring and got on his knee. Caitlin, of course, said, yes, and they spent the rest of the day celebrating with family and friends.