Nicholas and Madison’s story began through mutual friends from high school, even though they somehow never actually met in high school. Clearly, timing had other plans. Their paths finally crossed at Selma’s, which is very on-brand for Madison. She was there with friends for a birthday dinner, and Nicholas just happened to be their server. Somewhere between taking orders and doing his actual job, Nicholas decided to sit down and talk with Madison. Bold move, but apparently it worked! After leaving Selma’s, Madison did what any modern-day romantic would do: she found Nicholas on Instagram and slid into his DMs. About a week later, they went on their first date to see a movie. What started as a birthday dinner and a server taking a chance, and one brave Instagram message became the beginning of forever!