On Mallory's online dating profile where it listed her favorite foods, she wrote "cheese is all that matters." Nate knew that to be a true and factual statement, as his first message to her was that it was the "best thing" he "read in a profile in a while." Their first date was a few days later in February 2017 and, at the risk of being *cheesy* they have fallen more in love each day, and literally could not be happier to have found one another.