Natalie and Anthony met at work in 2017, when Anthony first saw her and thought she was gorgeous. After chatting it up, they set their first date at a local piano bar called the Golden Bee. Natalie jokingly tried to perform a ‘trust fall’ but actually slipped on ice; thankfully he was still able to catch her. Nineteen days later, Natalie felt herself falling head over heels again, this time in love. They went on a hike, ate some sushi, and ended the day watching the sunset at Fox Run Park - this is where Anthony officially asked Natalie to be his girlfriend!

Five years later on their anniversary, Anthony and Natalie went on a repeat adventure of their first date together: hiking, sushi, and ending the day at Fox Run Park. Unbeknownst to Natalie, he had “Big, Big Plans” – Anthony started with pulling out his camera and snapping pictures per their yearly tradition. Then all of a sudden soft, subtle music started to play by Chris Lane, and Anthony dropped to one knee, pulling out a ring. Shocked but overjoyed Natalie said, "Yes!"