On October 24th 2014, Colleen attended a late night performance of the 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee at Haddonfield Plays and Players. During the Act One Finale, as the actors danced through the audience, Katie landed on Colleen's lap, took the mini wine bottle she had out of her hand, drank it, and danced away. That was their first official meeting. However, it wouldn't be until the next production they both worked on at that theatre, Company, that they would really get to know each other. At a Holiday party on December 27th they found themselves talking all night. And on February 5th 2015, Katie finally mustered the nerve to ask Colleen to be her girlfriend. On August 22nd 2020 Katie proposed at their usual picture taking spot in Cape May. And on October 24th 2020 Colleen took Katie to the place it all began and proposed at Haddonfield Plays and Players. They are over the moon with excitement to come together on July 1st 2022 to say I do surrounded by all of their friends and family.