Cait and Greg met at the fraternity Pi Kapp at SUNY Plattsburgh! The clock struck midnight, and Greg was at the party drinking Coors Lights with his friends who were in the fraternity. After going to various Christmas parties all night, Cait walked into the party with a cheetah Santa hat on and was dancing with her friend. After dancing near Greg for a couple minutes, Greg asked Cait to dance just as the song Mr. Brightside by the Killers began to play, and the rest was history! The year before, Cait always told her friends she was going to meet her future husband at Pi Kapp. The stars truly aligned that cold Plattsburgh night!