Nick and Amber met on a dating site called "Plenty of Fish". After Amber and Nicholas talked over the site for three months & Nicholas asking several times to meet... On Amber's birthday, December 31, 2017, Nicholas secretly sent Amber chocolate covered strawberries to David's Bridal (where she was working at the time) and asked Amber for a date. After that first date, came many more dates, meeting each other's families, and Nicholas meeting Lilly... Then after two years of dating they decided to buy a home together. After a year living together, Nicholas thought it wasn't so bad to live with these two after all, and decided on December 02,2019 to FINALLY asked Amber and Lilly to be his forever.