Justine and Michael met on a lovely spring day at Riverside Park on the Upper West Side. Having recently moved to the city, Justine was interested in meeting new people and thought ultimate frisbee would be a great way to do so. Meanwhile, Michael planned to attend the same pickup game he'd been playing at for years. Little did either of them know this would be the day they met the love of their lives! Michael had eyes for Justine during the game and afterward suggested the group go to Harlem Tavern, hoping that she would decide to come along - and she did! Once they got to the bar, Justine and Michael coyly flirted and both tried to keep from seeming too excited. They parted ways that afternoon without exchanging numbers or having any firm plans to see each other again. The next week, Michael, hungover from his groomsmen Mike Glowacki's bachelor party, dragged himself to the game because he saw Justine had replied as attending. After pretending like he was there to play frisbee, Michael asked Justine if she would like to go on a date sometime, to which Justine replied yes - and the rest is history!