We first met on the Isles of the Broken Shore fighting hordes of demons. He was a strong and sexy demon-slaying warrior with a heart of gold. He leapt to the rescue of the beautiful priestess who struggled against the horde of demons that were after her. We often partied and quested together seeking the ultimate treasures. His ultimate quest, was to win her heart. And, this is how we met online, playing World of Warcraft...
We went to watch Fantastic Beasts, late one night. I tried to play footsie with her, but gave up too fast because I wasn't sure if she felt the same way. Maggie told me later that she expected me to make another move by trying to hold her hand but nothing happened for the rest of the movie. At my sister's yankee swap, I tried my foot at more footsies with Maggie. There was some reciprocation but I still wasn't sure, because I'm oblivious AF. She was fed up with my games and my not catching on, so she put her hand out and grabbed my hand. I finally got the hint that we shared the same feelings. So yeah, she made the first official move.
I plotted a scheme with my sisters and Patty, to surprise Maggie for the proposal. I immediately asked her mom for her daughter's hand in marriage. She allowed me to pursue the quest to wed her daughter. We set up cameras and decorated the home, and laid in wait for Maggie to come home. Her and my family were there laying in wait. Maggie was definitely surprised, but she basically came in the door and started laughing at me while I was on a knee.