On Matt and Noelle's first date at "Empanada Mama" in Hells Kitchen on the West Side of Manhattan, they had six empanadas, plantain chips with guacamole, and mojitos. Their server's name was Marco, and the date lasted two and a half hours. The details of this story are specific because Matt saved the receipt following the date. He knew he'd met someone special and wanted a memento to remind himself of that night. He drove Noelle home to her Upper East Side apartment, and they kissed goodnight. Exactly one year later, they were engaged.