Paul open enrolled his son, Liam, into school at St. Francis for his 4K year (Fall 2018). Liam had to stay at school full days, so he spent the morning in the 3K room, which was taught by Mary Catherine (MC). It was during open house for that school year that Paul saw MC for the first time. She caught his eye. The school year went on and Paul would walk Liam into school every morning and pick him up every day. Paul always talked to one of MC's coworkers, Erich Wallace, but always noticed MC was there in the morning and afternoon.