Josh and Katee met online and it was not love at first sight for these two. In fact, Josh said that their first date was one of the worst dates he's been on! To be fair, Katee tried to stand him up (twice). If it weren't for Katee's roommate at the time, Sydne, Katee never would have went on that first date to Hacienda for drinks. The very next night, Katee told Josh she was going to Franklin Street for Halloween and Josh offered to be her "Uber" driver. Katee must have redeemed herself because they've been inseparable ever since!

Josh told Katee that they were going to a fancy dinner with his Mom. Upon arriving to Biaggi's, Josh told Katee that he left his phone in the car and asked that she go and get it so that he could check them in. When Katee came back in, the hostess was waiting for her and took her to her seat. However, the hostess took her the wrong way. Thanks to a few employees and customers, Josh was able to swivel himself around and was ready when Katee turned the corner. Much to her surprise, there was Josh on one knee with a table full of family and friends behind him. She said yes before he even showed her the ring!