In July 2023, Allie visited her childhood best friend Mia in Chicago. When she arrived, the girls—along with Drew (Matt’s brother and Mia’s now-fiancé)—got ready to hit the town. At the first bar of the evening, Allie was introduced to Matt for the very first time. They quickly hit it off, fell for eachother, and the rest is history! By September 2023, Allie and Matt were officially dating. Matt moved to Cleveland just a few months later in March 2024, and in June 2025, they bought their first home together. He surprised her with a proposal in the magical Iveagh Gardens in Dublin, Ireland, in August 2025.