Caleb and Madison met for the first time at f/stop Fitzgerald Pub in Salem on the evening of Madison’s 24th birthday. They talked, drank beers, played an outdated version of Trivial Pursuit, laughed, closed down the bar, and soon deleted their dating apps for good.

She said yes on the beach in Waldport, OR, where many of the photos you see in our gallery were taken. With the help of Alea and Rudy Trevino, Caleb took advantage of a brief break in the cloud cover to ask Madison to marry him.