Anthony and Mackenzie met at 4th Street Bar & Grill in Columbus. They could not stop talking to one another and the chemistry was crazy from the get go. As it got later into the night the bar began to get extremely crowded and the two became separated from each other. Anthony, heartbroken and disappointed, walked back to his house telling his friends he had just met and lost his Great White Buffalo (for those who haven't seen Hot Tub Time Machine, Great White Buffalo means 'the one true love of your life and called the Great White Buffalo because of it's rarity, elusive status'). Mackenzie, too, was distressed and (maybe a little bit tipsy) and decided she just had to track Anthony down via social media that very night. Little did she know his father and him share the same name. She ended up messaging her soon-to-be father-in-law on Facebook, who promptly wrote back letting her know she was unfortunately mistaking him for his son. Mackenzie was mortified but Tony Rini, Sr. promised not to spill the beans to his son. He hoped Mackenzie and Tony Jr. would meet again. Mackenzie and Tony both went to the same bar the following Thursday searching for one another...and they've been a packaged deal ever since.