We connected on Coffee Meets Bagel and arranged to meet at a bar called Dynaco in Bedford-Stuyvesant. Becca noticed that the bar offered goldfish, a snack her students adore. Jonathan joked that she could take some home for her cat Sammy, which puzzled Becca as she didn’t see goldfish crackers as cat food. On the night of the date, Becca was on the lookout for goldfish crackers, while Jonathan was expecting to see a fish tank. They shared a good laugh over the mix-up.