While both attending a Halloween party at a friend's house, Dalton was dressed as "Archie Andrews" and Lindsey was dressed as "Betty Cooper" from the hit show "Riverdale." Initially mistaken as a couple, they were encouraged to take a photo together. One week later, Lindsey and Dalton ran into each other again at yet another Halloween party, where they ended up talking all night at the bar "High Fives" and shortly after had their first official date.