Leslie and her roommates threw an ugly sweater Christmas party in December, 2015. Leslie was in grad school at Rowan University with Andrew's brother, Josh. Andrew was home for winter break from St. Francis University, and Josh thought that Andrew and Leslie would hit it off. So, Josh brought Andrew to the party to meet Leslie. Even though Leslie had another date that night, Andrew made a lasting impression on her. A year and a half later, Andrew and Leslie went on their first date. Christmas is the most special time of year for the couple.