We were friends first...we'll kind of. We met back in high school at just 16 years old. We had mutual friends, attended all the same gatherings and little did we know we even shared the same birthday. So while we didn't date in high school, Jeremy definitely tried to get Lesley's attention. Many times. It wasn't until four years later that she finally took notice. A chance text led to a first date, that happened to land on Valentine's Day.