We met 4 years ago, bonding instantly over our mutual love for the Yankees. He said to me, "If the Yankees win this playoff game, I'll pay for dinner. If they lose, you pay." I said, "How about if they win, you GET to take me to dinner." The following week, we went out on our first date. We realized we had way more in common than just our love for the Yankees, and we haven't stopped realizing that ever since. 3 years later, he proposed, and the rest is history.