Jermaine and Olivia both graduated Allegheny College in 2011 but neither of them had ever met or spoken to each other in their four years there. They both were at their 5 year college reunion (Olivia was working it, Jermaine was celebrating). Olivia can remember her good friend pulling her into a lounge Jermaine and his friends were hanging out in and said "you never know, your husband could be in there". Olivia did not meet Jermaine that night but she did hit on one of his friends (oops!). Eventually they met on Bumble of all places. They both kind of knew the other person from College and that they'd never met them. Once they started talking Olivia said she wasn't looking for anything serious because she was interviewing for a job in DC. Jermaine was in the middle of football season at Gannon where he was coaching. A month and a half later, they had a day and time for their first date, then Jermaine's car broke down so it was delayed by a few hours. Eventually though, they met at a great bar in Meadville (RIP 1776) and ended up shuting it down because they talked until 2am. And the rest, as they say, is history.