While they were dating (and Kristin was not so subtly dropping engagement hints), Nick teased that Kristin would be lucky to get a Ring Pop when he proposed. This become a running joke throughout the relationship. On the day of the proposal, Nick took Kristin to a park, told her how much he loved her and pulled a ring box out of his pocket. Inside the ring box was a large plastic Ring Pop. Nick slid the top off the Ring Pop, and the engagement ring was inside!