Ben and Caitlin met each other at a Halloween party that Caitlin wasn't even supposed to be at. They instantly hit it off but due to some roommate wandering, only Ben was able to give Caitlin his number. Being the height of Nutcracker season, Caitlin was way too busy for boys. Meanwhile Ben was frantically trying to track down the "black swan ballerina" from the party. Towards the end of November, Caitlin finally had time for a date, she got in touch with Ben and they've been together ever since. Ben snuck an engagement ring on their trip to Iceland and proposed towards the end of the trip. After struggling to find a "perfect moment", instead they created one.