Kendyl and Nicholas met in high school, where mutual friends decided to play matchmaker. Nick, being just bold enough, sent Morgan out as his wingwoman to ask Kendyl the all-important question: Did she like Nick? Kendyl’s legendary response? “I could.” (High praise, honestly.) That was all the confidence Nick needed. With this glowing endorsement, Nick officially asked Kendyl out, and their first date happened on November 13th, 2020. What started as a teenage crush quickly turned into something much bigger—full of laughter, love, and probably a few debates about where to eat. Fast forward almost five years to June 17th, 2025. While vacationing in the Abacos, Kendyl thought the Stalker family simply wanted some nice sunset beach photos. Completely innocent. Totally unsuspecting. What she didn’t know was that everyone was in on a very well-kept secret. As the sun set, Nick had secretly handed Karly a glass bottle with a note inside. While photos were being taken, Karly and Ronnie casually buried the bottle in the sand like it was no big deal. Kendyl “discovered” it moments later, and before she could fully process what was happening, Nick was down on one knee asking her to spend forever with him. She said yes (this time, very confidently), and the rest is history. From a hesitant “I could” to a definite “I do,” Kendyl and Nicholas can’t wait to start their next chapter together.