We were both in the same LDS singles ward up in Rexburg, Idaho but had never met until one day we both showed up late for a church activity. The activity was pretty much over by the time we both got to the church building that evening but we both felt like we needed to show up there anyways. Mathew saw me sitting by myself in the church hallway and came up and introduced himself to me. We had a nice conversation, he asked me out to sushi, I said yes (even though I hated sushi) and the rest is history.