Jamie hates going out and drinking with his friends. Lucky for Kelsey, he decided to hit a local bar with some of his college buddies one fateful night in February, just a week before COVID. Kelsey was out and about exploring Cleveland as she had just moved there. Through mutual friends, the two ended up together at the Flying Monkey. After losing a few games of darts, Jamie bought Kelsey a peanut butter and jelly shot, and the rest was history.