Kayla and Peter met when they were just 15 years old when Peter became best friends with Kayla's brother, Kyle. Since day one, Kayla and Peter had a (not so) secret crush but it wasn't until many years of flirtation later they would realize what they had was much more than that. It was Kayla's nieces birthday party that brought them back together. When they realized there was still an undeniable spark, they decided to give things a shot. At the time, Peter was living in Boston and Kayla was living in Tampa. After exactly six visits back and forth, they knew it was the real deal and Kayla moved to Boston.

There was a three month lineup of fun fueled trips scheduled for Springtime, one of them being New York. Kayla had never been so Peter planned a trip to the city as a Christmas present. Little did she know, there was much more planned than she thought. On the very first night before dinner and a concert, they headed out for a quick trip to Bryant Park. It was chilly, outdoor lights were strung and at a little table in the middle of the park Peter asked her to spend the rest of her life with him. After shock and tears, she took the ring and put it on her own finger. Peter took that as a yes.